Northern Virginia vs. St. Johns: What I Learned Moving from Ashburn to Florida
If you're in Northern Virginia and wondering whether moving to Florida actually adds up, I've been exactly where you are. I made the move myself, from Ashburn to St. Johns, and I ran the numbers before I did.
Here's an honest side-by-side of what changed: home prices, income tax, car tax, property tax, insurance, and the one thing Ashburn neighbors keep asking me about: data centers. Spoiler: Florida doesn't win every category, and I'll show you exactly where Virginia comes out ahead.
Home prices: more house for the money
The median home in St. Johns costs about $253,000 less than the median home in Loudoun County.
- Loudoun County, VA: $758,500 median sale price (September 2026)
- St. Johns, FL (32259): $505,000 median sale price (12 months through November 19, 2026)
Medians vary a lot by neighborhood and home type, but many buyers from the D.C. area find the same budget goes a lot further here.
State income tax: keep more of your paycheck
Florida has no state income tax. Virginia's top rate is 5.75%, which kicks in on taxable income over $17,000.
To make that real, I ran the numbers at Loudoun County's median household income of $181,765. For a married couple taking Virginia's 2026 standard deduction, that's about $9,100 a year in Virginia state income tax, or roughly $91,000 over 10 years. In Florida: $0.
Virginia also taxes capital gains as regular income, while Florida has no state capital gains tax. Everyone's tax picture is different, so please run your own numbers with a CPA.
Goodbye, car tax bill
Virginians know this one: every year, Loudoun County taxes your car's value. At the 2026 rate of $3.09 per $100, a $50,000 vehicle costs about $1,545 a year. Got two cars in the driveway? Double it.
Florida has no annual personal property tax on your car. You'll still pay vehicle registration fees, but that yearly bill disappears.
Property tax: an honest moment
This is the one category where Virginia wins on the rate.
- Loudoun County: $0.805 per $100 of assessed value in 2026, about 0.8%
- St. Johns: about 13 to 15 mills, or roughly 1.3% to 1.5%, depending on location and taxing district
Florida softens that in two ways. The homestead exemption* takes up to $51,411 off your primary home's taxable value in 2026. And once you're homesteaded, a cap on increases keeps your assessed value from jumping with the market.
At each county's median price, the yearly bills land in the same neighborhood: about $6,100 in Loudoun at $758,500, and about $5,500 to $7,000 in St. Johns at roughly $505,000 with homestead.
New! Amendment 3 passed on November 3, 2026 with 62% of the vote. It raises Florida's homestead exemption for non-school property taxes to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028. One important detail for my Virginia friends: if you're not a Florida resident by December 31, 2026, you start with the current exemption, and the bigger one begins in your fifth year. Details may still change with 2027 implementing legislation.
*The home must qualify as your permanent primary residence, and you must apply with the county property appraiser.
Good to know: when you buy in Florida, the home's assessed value resets to your purchase price, so budget your taxes on what you pay, not the current owner's bill.
"But isn't Florida insurance crazy?"
It depends a lot on where in Florida. In St. Johns, insurance lands in the same ballpark as Virginia:
- Virginia average: $2,265 a year, statewide
- St. Johns estimate: about $1,296 to $3,456+ a year for a typical home, with newer roofs landing lower
For comparison, Florida's statewide average was $8,292 in 2025. I chose St. Johns over South Florida partly because of lower insurance costs, and we made sure not to buy in a flood zone to keep costs down.
My tip: get real quotes and check the flood zone before you make an offer.
Data centers in your backyard?
This was a big one for me. Loudoun County has 253 data centers covering about 49 million square feet, with dozens more already approved. In St. Johns County, commissioners unanimously approved a county-wide one-year moratorium on large-scale data centers in November 2026, running through October 31, 2027, citing water and electricity use.
What Loudoun neighbors deal with:
- Wooded land cleared for massive, windowless buildings
- HOA lawsuits over noise
- New transmission lines near neighborhoods and schools
- Residents linking higher power bills to data centers
- Water: data centers' share of Potomac basin water use is 2% to 8% today, projected up to 33% by 2050
The electric bill difference is real, too. A typical 1,000 kWh month runs about $180 with Dominion Energy in Northern Virginia, compared with about $133 with FPL in Northeast Florida, before taxes and fees. Your utility and bill depend on your address and usage.
To be fair, there's a trade-off: data centers fund about 45% of Loudoun's county and school budget, which is one reason its property tax rate is lower.
Why I chose St. Johns
When I left Ashburn, here's what was on my own list:
- A tax shelter: no state income tax, plus the homestead exemption
- Insurance in the same ballpark: and we made sure not to buy in a flood zone to keep costs lower than if we'd moved to South Florida
- No more car tax bill: about $1,545 a year on a $50K car in Loudoun; here, $0
- No data centers in my backyard: they were going up all around my house in Ashburn. I don't see any in my community, Ponte Vedra or St. Augustine.
I found all of it here.
Relocation tip if you're selling up north: with the federal home-sale exclusion, when you sell a primary home you've owned and lived in for at least 2 of the past 5 years, up to $250,000 of profit ($500,000 for married couples) is generally excluded from federal tax. It's a federal rule that applies in every state, so ask your CPA how it fits your sale.
The recap
|
|
Northern Virginia |
St. Johns |
|---|---|---|
|
Median home |
$758,500. |
$505,000 |
|
State income tax |
Up to 5.75% |
0% |
|
Car tax |
~$1,545/yr on a $50K car |
$0 |
|
Property tax |
~0.8% (lower rate) |
~1.3–1.5% + homestead* |
|
Insurance |
VA avg. $2,265/yr |
Est. $1,296– $3,456+/yr |
|
Electric bill (1,000 kWh) |
~$180/mo |
~$133/mo |
|
Data centers |
253 in Loudoun |
Paused county- wide |
Ready to see the savings for yourself?
If you're considering relocating from Northern Virginia and want a firsthand look at the savings, book your free call with me! I've made this exact move, and I'd love to help you run your own numbers.
Jennifer Mandrgoc | eXp Realty | Northeast Florida | 443-834-4911 | @relocatewithjennifer
This article is for general information only and is not tax, legal or financial advice. Figures are estimates from the sources below, change often and vary by property. Please consult a qualified professional about your specific situation.
Sources
- Northern Virginia Association of Realtors data via Weekly Real Estate News – Northern Virginia, September 2026
- Move With Momentum – St. Johns, FL 32259 housing market
- U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts – Loudoun County, VA
- VisaVerge – Virginia 2026 brackets and standard deduction
- Loudoun County – Tax year 2026 adopted rates
- DJ & Lindsey – St. Johns vs. Duval property taxes
- News4JAX – Florida voters pass Amendment 3
- Florida Chamber – Amendment 3
- NerdWallet – Virginia homeowners insurance
- Move With Momentum – Home insurance cost in Saint Johns, FL
- Commercial Observer – How data centers changed Loudoun County
- Jax Today – St. Johns County approves data center moratorium
- WTVR – Dominion bill projections
- FPL – Residential rates, October 2026
Categories
Recent Posts








