New Build or Resale? Pros and Cons of Buying in St. Johns County, Florida
New Build or Resale? Pros and Cons of Buying in St. Johns County, Florida
Oct 19, 2026 · @Jennifer
Brand-new and shiny, or established and full of character? If you're shopping in St. Johns County, you'll face this choice fast, because new construction is everywhere here. And right now, the decision is more interesting than ever.
In Northeast Florida, new homes used to carry a big premium over existing ones. That gap has nearly disappeared: new homes priced about 39% higher than existing homes in 2011, but the difference shrank to 0.3% in 2025, and so far in 2026 new homes are pricing slightly below existing homes per square foot. So let's break down the real pros and cons of each, so you can choose what fits your family.
At a glance
|
Factor |
New construction |
Resale |
|---|---|---|
|
Price per square foot (NE Florida, 2026) |
Slightly below existing homes so far this year |
Slightly above new homes so far this year |
|
Incentives |
Builders often offer incentives, such as design center credits, pool credits, or rate buydowns |
Depends on the individual seller- I've seen fence credits, or CDD's paid in full |
|
Move-in timing |
8-12 Months for a to-be-built home; sooner for a |
Typically a standard closing timeline |
|
Customization |
Choose finishes and options |
What you see is what you get, or renovate later |
|
Insurance |
Newer homes often cost less to insure, |
Roof age and home age can raise costs, |
|
Maintenance |
New systems and roof |
Older systems may need updating sooner |
|
Neighborhood |
Still growing; construction nearby, full amenities may not be built yet |
Established, with mature landscaping |
|
Fees |
Often HOA and in some communities CDD fees |
Varies; may have HOA, CDD or neither |
New construction: the pros and cons
The pros
- Builder incentives. Builders are actively using incentives and some even offer mortgage rate buydowns to attract buyers. In a July 2026 national survey, 63% of builders offered sales incentives. Incentives change often, so ask what's available right now.
- Everything is new. New roof, new systems, new appliances, and the chance to pick finishes you love.
- Potential insurance savings. In St. Johns County, estimated annual premiums for a typical home range from about $1,296 to $3,456 or more. A newer roof and wind-mitigation credits push toward the low end, while an older roof pushes toward the high end. Wind-mitigation credits can reduce the wind portion of a premium by 15% to 40%.
- Amenity-rich communities. Many new master-planned communities in St. Johns County come with pools, trails, clubhouses and community events.
The cons
- Waiting time. A to-be-built home can take 8-12 months. That can be great for relocating buyers who need time to sell up north, or frustrating if you need to move fast.
- CDD fees. Many master-planned communities have a Community Development District assessment on the property tax bill, in addition to HOA dues. It typically includes a bond portion that pays for community infrastructure and an ongoing maintenance portion. Ask for the exact amount for the specific lot.
- A neighborhood still in progress. Expect construction traffic, young landscaping and amenities that may still be coming.
- Construction quality still needs checking. New doesn't mean perfect. Getting your own independent inspection during the build is a smart move.
- Schools may shift. In a fast-growing county, new schools open and zones change. Verify the current school zone for the address.
Resale: the pros and cons
The pros
- Move in sooner. No build timeline to wait out, which can be a big help if your job or school calendar is set.
- Established neighborhoods. Mature trees, finished amenities and a settled community you can see before you buy.
- Location options. Some of the most sought-after spots, closer to the beaches or historic areas, are often already built out.
- Room to make it yours. Older homes can offer larger lots or more character, with the option to update over time.
The cons
- Older systems and roofs. Some components may need replacing sooner, so a thorough inspection matters.
- Insurance can cost more. Roof age and home age can affect what you pay for homeowners insurance in Florida. Get quotes before you make an offer.
- Updates cost money. Dated kitchens, baths or finishes may need a budget of their own.
- Less flexibility on incentives. Every seller is different, and resale sellers may not offer the kinds of incentives builders sometimes do.
Good to know for either choice: in Florida, when you buy, the home's assessed value for property taxes resets to your purchase price, while long-time owners benefit from a cap on increases. Budget your taxes on the purchase price, not the current owner's bill.
Which one fits you?
Ask yourself:
- When do you need to move? A firm date leans toward resale or a move-in-ready spec home. A flexible timeline opens up a to-be-built home.
- Do you want to pick your finishes, or move in and relax?
- How important is an established neighborhood versus the newest amenities?
- What's your total monthly budget? Include insurance, HOA and CDD fees, not just the mortgage.
- Are you relocating from out of state? If so, think about who will keep an eye on a build while you're still up north.
How I help, whichever you choose
As a new-home-certified agent, I help buyers stay on top of the latest builder incentives, keep track of timelines and deliverables during the build, and be your local eyes on the property if you're buying from out of state. I'll also make sure you get your own independent inspection during construction. Prefer resale? I'll help you compare established neighborhoods and plan for the costs older homes can bring.
Ready to talk through your options? Let's find the right fit for your family.
Jennifer Mandrgoc | eXp Realty | Northeast Florida 443-834-4911 | @relocatewithjennifer
This article is for general information only. Prices, incentives and fees change often, so verify current details for any specific home or community.
Sources
Categories
Recent Posts







